Precious Metals Watch – Positive on platinum, negative on gold

by: Georgette Boele

150701-Precious-Metals-Watch.pdf (776 KB)
  • Q2 has brought weakness in precious metal prices…
  • …and we expect this to continue in Q3…
  • …with the exception of platinum prices, which should start recovering
  • Gold to be the worst performing precious metal over the coming year
  • Silver prices to recover later in the year but not yet

Q2 has brought weakness in prices

Precious metal prices fell sharply in the second quarter of this year. The most resilient precious metal was gold (-1%), which was supported by a downward adjustment in Fed interest rate expectations, a weak US dollar and the Greek saga. However, higher US Treasury yields weighed on prices. In addition, gold demand from China was weaker than expected. More importantly, the sell-off in palladium prices also dragged down other precious metals.

Indeed, after being the strongest precious metals for quite some time, gravity also caught up with in palladium prices (      -8%). What does not want to go up on relatively strong fundamentals, had to go down. In short, speculative investors exited palladium positions in Q2 (see graph below).

150701- PM1

How did our forecasts perform?

We had expected substantial price weakness in the second quarter. The direction proved to be correct (see graph below). However, price weakness in gold, silver and palladium was less than we had foreseen. At the start of Q2 our end-of-June palladium forecast of USD 650 per ounce looked very unrealistic, but in the end we were not that far off. Our view was that if investors started to liquidate positions, palladium prices would be sold off sharply. This scenario played out.

150701- PM2

In terms of our average forecasts, the direction was again correct, but our forecasts were for more substantial down-moves than that materialized in the end. In case of our platinum average Q2 forecast, we were very close to the actual average for Q2 with a difference of only 0.8% (graph below).

150701- PM3

Our base scenario has not changed

Our base scenario has not changed. This includes the following pillars

–       The US economy to steam ahead…

–       …and the Fed to hike interest rates in September

–       The Fed to hike more in 2015 and 2016 than financial markets currently anticipate

–       Financial markets to adjust to the new reality of Fed rate hikes and to adjust upwards their rate hike expectations

–       Inflation expectations to remain muted

–       The US dollar to rally another 10% in trade-weighted terms this year

–       Investor sentiment to be constructive shaking off the Greek saga

–       The eurozone economy to improve…

–       …and China to avoid a hard landing

What does this mean for our precious metals price outlook?

We remain bearish on gold for 2015 and 2016

Higher US interest rates and a higher US dollar will be strong headwinds for precious metals prices. Higher US interest rates make investment assets that pay virtually no income relatively unattractive. Precious metals are among these assets. In addition, a higher US dollar weighs on precious metal prices (see graph below). It is likely that in such an environment investors will liquidate speculative positions in precious metals.

150701- PM4

Gold prices are the most negatively affected in our view, mainly because investor and jewellery demand are very important for the price outlook. Investors will likely liquidate gold positions when US dollar and US rates go up in an environment that inflation expectations remain muted and investor sentiment is constructive.  Moreover, gold has a relatively low share of industrial demand. However, we expect Chinese gold demand, especially jewellery demand, to improve and this should dampen the downside somewhat.

150701- PM5

Silver prices to remain closely tied to gold’s performance

Silver prices remain closely tied to gold’s fate in the near-term. Furthermore, silver supply has increased at a faster pace than was originally anticipated. So a higher US dollar, higher US rates, gold price weakness and higher supply should drive down silver prices. However, we expect industrial demand for silver to provide some support. The gold/silver ratio (see graph above) is at extreme levels. This means that gold is expensive compared to silver. It is likely that silver will outperform gold prices going forward (weakening less than gold). At some point in the coming weeks and months, silver prices should be able to disconnect from gold prices. This will be later than we had originally envisaged.

150701- PM6

More investor position liquidation to push palladium lower

We remain negative on palladium prices for the coming months. It is likely that a combination of ample above-ground stocks, higher-than-expected supply, lower industrial and autocatalyst’ demand and investors further liquidating positions will push palladium prices lower. Palladium has a substantial exposure to emerging markets. With economies in emerging markets being weaker than foreseen, demand for palladium will likely be lower than expected. We expect another negative quarter for palladium prices.

We turn positive on platinum!

More substantial mine supply, a higher US dollar and higher US rates and weakness in other precious metals are serious headwinds for platinum prices. However, other developments are far more positive in our view. First, we remain positive on the eurozone economic outlook despite Greece. The eurozone is very important market for platinum autocatalyst demand. In addition, we expect jewellery demand from China to improve. This is also a crucial source of demand for platinum. What is more, speculative shorts in platinum on the futures markets are very extreme. Net-positions in platinum are close to lows seen since 2012 (see graphs bellows).

150701- PM7

150701- PM8

Last, but not least the gold/platinum ratio is in extreme territory. It is increasingly likely that this ratio will start moving in favour of platinum. This would translate in gold prices selling off more aggressively than platinum prices, platinum prices rising faster than gold prices or gold prices falling while platinum prices recover. We opt for the third scenario given that cyclical demand will  support platinum prices.

150701- PM9

150701- PM10